Joined: 05 Sep 2006 Posts: 2 Location: Brooklyn, NY
Posted: Tue Sep 05, 2006 11:19 pm Post subject: Posting recipes from other people/books/blogs?
I tried doing a search for a similar topic but it was a little tough, so forgive me if this is repetitive...
I'm wondering what the protocol is for posting recipes in my blog. I know I can post my own, but what about recipes from cookbooks or other blogs? I am assuming that it can be done, as long as they are properly cited. Is that true? If so, I would be so grateful if someone can point me to a good resource for that type of citation.
Joined: 17 Aug 2005 Posts: 307 Location: Far, far away
Posted: Wed Sep 06, 2006 12:10 am Post subject:
Full attribution and complete citations are critical, of course, but there are other considerations, including motivation.
There have been lengthy discussions of this issue on other Web sites, especially concerning copyright law and recipes as intellectual property. I believe the current thinking is that the text of a recipe is the author's own and protected by copyright law. For example, in today's entry by Clotilde on her pistachio "pound cake," the charming preface to the list of ingredients is protected as is the wording of the instructions.
However, even if she were the first to make a pistachio pound cake (I believe she says her inspiration came from elsewhere), she cannot prevent others from publishing or posting recipes for pistachio pound cake. The new author would not be vulnerable to law suits even if he were to copy the ingredients from C & Z exactly. However, instructions would have to be worded differently and the intro, of course, would be utterly different.
Most people would be more scrupulous than that and in all cases, would give full credit.
That said, few people in the culinary world manage to support a family of four on the money they earn, let alone own more than one home as is the case with some of the most celebrated. What they do earn from the sale of books matters. By publishing the recipe on your site, you lessen the incentive for your blog's readers to buy the book and in turn, for the author to benefit from the interest you raise.
There's another way to look at this, though. A major, recognized culinary site sometimes publishes recipes from cookbooks verbatim AS an incentive for readers to buy the book. This is done with the author's consent.
The source for making the rice pudding is acknowledged and link provided. If you look at his other classic on Janet Jackson Breast Cupcakes, you'll see that Adam (right?) just identifies his recipe. The point for him is to be creative, not just perform the recipe accurately. (The other point is to be funny, earn praise, feel validated and so on.)
What bothers me most is a recipe presented as something original as well as novel when it is not. Credit should always be given for the source of inspiration with an explanation of the debt and tweaking that occurred.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum